RMIB posted a response to a post I made some pages back. I can't find it. He made some good points re fans critiquing coaches, like Popa, for the Socceroos.
Rightly or wrongly, I believe some posters on G and G, not our Socceroo hating posters from the right wing nut job forum who troll G and G, but genuine Socceroo fans who always appear disgruntled with whomever the Socceroo coach is - at any given point in time. For the record I think all of Ange, Bert, Arnie and Popa have been effective coaches for the Socceroos. I thought Holger was the wrong coach - which was raised a lot in national coaching conferences with Han Berger.
For the first 2 games in this WCQ round, the final round, Australia lost to Bahrain (with stats showing we should have won decisively), and drew with Indo in Jakarta. Again the match stats showed we should have won in Jakarta.
Then Arnie quit. He said he had lost the plot since the Asian Cup. I admire his honesty.
I don't believe Popa has had enough credit on this forum for:
* In 6 games since taking over from Arnie, Popa has accrued 3 wins and 3 draws. In doing so, he has turned the Socceroo WCQ campaign around. Aus is now 2nd on the table by 3 points. I think some posters on G and G should be more positive about Popa's tenure, given these results and the turnaround.
* Popa has had considerable success selecting A L players that Arnie ignored, like Geria, Villupillay, Borrello, Matthews, Caceres, Taggart, Teague and Arzani. All have showed they value add to the team based on performance. If you disagree on any of these players, I'll set out why they have been an asset. On the other hand, Brattan struggled against the best team. How about some Popa love for his AL selections?
* Arnie ( and I agree with almost everything he did and said) perplexingly said because Strain, Miller and Gethyn Jones were injured, and Atkinson was clubless, he had to play Circati at RB. How did he fail to identify Geria, now one of the Socceroos best players? Geria is far better than Geraint Jones as RB too.
How about some plaudits for Popa for the Geria selection as a Right CB in a back three? In 1 v1 stats, Jason G is the best ball winner in the team in those 6 games when he has been on the pitch.
* Popa's 3-4-3 flat midfield in Ball Possession, manifesting as 5-2-3, and 5-4-1 in Ball Possession Opposition has worked well, in terms of results. It is a conventional Dutch KNVB formation and a derivative of the 1-4-3-3 system. Why are some so sceptical?
* Senior players like Irvine and Ryan, claim Popa's attention to fine detail for game plans, and even diet, is quite a step up. That it has value added to players individually - and - as a team unit. How about some more Popa love?
* Popa has moved away from selecting players in the Scottish league, outside the Old Firm. Only 3 players from Hibs were in the recent squad. It is the antithesis to Arnie. Popa's decision has brought more success.
* It appears to me, that some posters rationalise that any player playing anywhere in Europe, has to be better than any A L player - and - our veteran Socceroos.
UEFA is diverse and heterogeneous. There is a chasm between the UEFA Big Five league clubs, as well as the Big 30- 40 clubs who play in Lower UEFA Leagues, but regularly play Champ and Europa league football on the one hand ( Ajax, Sporting Lisbon, Benfica, PSV, Porto, Feyenoorde, Young Boys, Anderlecht, maybe Celtic, et al) , and the rest of UEFA.
Recently I've seen a lot more Italian Serie A teams play, and Scottish league teams. The difference between most of the Scottish league teams and Serie A teams, is enormous in quality ( sorry Lurker). AL teams play a style of football much closer to Serie A teams, than Scotland does. Having said this, Celtic play superb football.
* There also appears to be a prevailing view, that there are these amazing Aussie players not selected, or in Socceroo squads, who aren't getting Socceroo game time. That they are far better than the Socceroo incumbents - Popa just can't see it though.
Any coach sees how players perform relative to each other in camp. Some combine much better with each other, than other players. There was a profound difference between Behich and Davidson at LB a few years ago in terms of playing fluently and cohesively with players around them when they played Socceroo LB.
Experience is absolutely paramount. Some veteran players like Irvine, Ryan, Behich and Goodwin, may be peaking in their 30s. Their bodies are holding up, and their experience means they make few mistakes, and make good decisions, plus have very good positioning in a team context.
Their game sense continues to improve. Moreover, they mentor inexperienced players around them. They may have great leadership qualities too.
End of rant.