Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

Sign Up Now!

World news and politics.

Monoethnic Social Club said:
just as a question around this... which Zionist target was the Hamas operation of October 7th attacking? I mean sure, the stated Aim is to fight agaisnt the Zionist
Click to expand...
It was a concern on stolen lands, not far from the Gazan border..
Football us life said:
Here's a problem I have.

The trotting out of the word 'Islamophobe' which can often imply that someone is a bigot or racist ..

There is no race of Muslims. Islam is a religion, a system of ideas, subscribed to by people of every race and ethnicity. It’s just like Christianity in that regard. Christianity and Islam are both aggressively missionary faiths, and they win converts from everywhere.

We are critical towards Christianity all the time and with very good reason. At times it's an abhorrent religion. And we constantly worry about its political and social influences but no one confuses this for bigotry against Christians as people.

There’s no such thing as 'Christophobia'....
Click to expand...
It doesn't imply, it states clearly.

What is happening is that you have a mirror held up and can't accept when you are called out for it. So anti-Semitism exists and is abhorrent, but every other religion is open season to be criticised, no matter if that criticism is false, incites hatred, or spreads bigotry.

Islamaphobia is a dislike or prejudice against Muslims or Islam. You and js96 have made many statement that meet that definition. If you don't like it, then reflect and be better.
 
zimbos05 said:
When I said Facebook mom posts, you were like, for sure.

We have segregated gyms. Not Muslim owned or invented, why can't women request their own space at the school? Our school has a girls only gym. Absolutely no boys allowed to use it, not even male teachers. No one demands segregated activities, it just happens. In all schools.

Oh no, a person wants a day off work to celebrate their religious holiday. The entire Gregorian calendar caters to Christian holidays, but heaven forbid someone else wants to celebrate their religious holiday. We're not demanding. We ask, and we use sick leave, or paid or unpaid leave.

Not seen a single school demand food be removed for religious reasons.

I have seen schools demand Staff and teachers sign contracts denouncing being gay or lesbian. We have a whole Catholic system that I can never get a job in simply because of my religion. In fact I was rejected from a school not based on experience or anything, but simply because, "you're not Christian, which means we can't trust your character as you can't get a priest letter".

Yes, those are the exact words said to me. I guess that discrimination is ok, but asking for a day off to celebrate a religious holiday is horrible.
Click to expand...
I don't condone anything in the Catholic system and that's something that needs to be removed. Schools shouldn't have any religious affiliation.

Australia is thankfully slower in the food aspect but it's rampant across Europe. We don't have cafeterias as such.

Most Christian religious holidays don't have any religious weight for the average Australian and that's the way to go. It's not like public holidays will be removed from the calendar. Besides, many progressions need to work on those days.
 
JS96 said:
Islamophobia was invented to deny discussion about any concerning matter. The issue is too many of any faith for that matter, keep reverting their viewpoints and decisions back to fucking books from the stone age. How backwards can you be to refer to some texts based on heresay when you won't believe a mate's story from the night out before?

Ironic the term was invented when phobias are considered as irrational fears. So they used the word which means it doesn't exist to portray something they think should exist to give themselves something to stand on?

You have a phobia about me! Why would you create that when phobias are things that don't make sense in the first place?
Click to expand...
I've been called an 'Islamophobe' on several occasions, in real life of course, not counting here in internet-land by ol' mate Zimbo's....

But despite several robust discussions with Muslims about Islam, Sharia Law and their place in our modern society never by a Muslim. And having lived for many years in London I've known numerous Muslims.

I've found that they are mostly genuinely intrigued by my questioning and my criticism. But I have been called an 'Islamophobe' by non Muslims, its usually been by white middle class liberal types when discussing the pro's and cons of Islam.

Admittedly I do have many reservations about Sharia Law, particularly concerning it's relationship with people from the LGBTQi community who are often subjected to ubiquitous condemnation of their sexuality by purveyors of Sharia Law. And that's an LGBTQi community which the middle class white liberals usually tend to be sympathetic towards.

In my experience Muslims are generally quite cool about my reservations. Others I've mentioned super quick to trott out the 'Islamophobe' tag...
 
zimbos05 said:
It was a concern on stolen lands, not far from the Gazan border..

It doesn't imply, it states clearly.

What is happening is that you have a mirror held up and can't accept when you are called out for it. So anti-Semitism exists and is abhorrent, but every other religion is open season to be criticised, no matter if that criticism is false, incites hatred, or spreads bigotry.

Islamaphobia is a dislike or prejudice against Muslims or Islam. You and js96 have made many statement that meet that definition. If you don't like it, then reflect and be better.
Click to expand...
Is Zionophobia greater than or equal to Islamophobia? You seem pretty quick to push others to "reflect" but you don't set the same path for yourself. Is your mirror somehow different?

Your "stolen lands" justification of killing innocent people (if thats what you mean) is disgusting... sorry but it really is.... How can indiscriminate killing of unarmed people be justifiable? -- And before you bother - OTHER crimes have been committed in the name of other other beliefs and they are also equally vile.... what makes Hamas and their cause above basic humanity? because they have suffered for 70 years? So what? Other, alot worthier, people have suffered for centuries.... If my neighbour builds a new fence and "steals" 10cms of my property, I fight him in court, Im not gonna rape his wife and drag his dead body through the mud.....
 
JS96 said:
I don't condone anything in the Catholic system and that's something that needs to be removed. Schools shouldn't have any religious affiliation.

Australia is thankfully slower in the food aspect but it's rampant across Europe. We don't have cafeterias as such.

Most Christian religious holidays don't have any religious weight for the average Australian and that's the way to go. It's not like public holidays will be removed from the calendar. Besides, many progressions need to work on those days.
Click to expand...
Don't bring what's happening in Europe and making like it happens here. I don't know the European cases you speak of because never heard of them. However, you're doing exactly what you claim not to be. You're spreading dear workout justification. You're generalising a whole people based on one incident in a different continent.

Doesn't matter if they have weight or not.That's a personal choice. Just because you choose to follow a less religious path, doesn't mean everyone should. Fortunately I don't have to anymore, but I'm my previous career I worked every Christmas, new year, Easter, so my colleagues could have that time off with their family. I never questioned how religious they were. I just respected their holiday. You not respecting ours is bigotry
 
JS96 said:
I don't condone anything in the Catholic system and that's something that needs to be removed. Schools shouldn't have any religious affiliation.

Australia is thankfully slower in the food aspect but it's rampant across Europe. We don't have cafeterias as such.

Most Christian religious holidays don't have any religious weight for the average Australian and that's the way to go. It's not like public holidays will be removed from the calendar. Besides, many progressions need to work on those days.
Click to expand...
Don't agree... Private schools have EVERY right to practice, pray, teach in whatever manner they chose provided they adhere to the Education departments core curriculum and basic Australian law.
 
Football us life said:
I've been called an 'Islamophobe' on several occasions, in real life of course, not counting here in internet-land by ol' mate Zimbo's....

But despite several robust discussions with Muslims about Islam, Sharia Law and their place in our modern society never by a Muslim. And having lived for many years in London I've known numerous Muslims.

I've found that they are mostly genuinely intrigued by my questioning and my criticism. But I have been called an 'Islamophobe' by non Muslims, its usually been by white middle class liberal types when discussing the pro's and cons of Islam.

Admittedly I do have many reservations about Sharia Law, particularly concerning it's relationship with people from the LGBTQi community who are often subjected to ubiquitous condemnation of their sexuality by purveyors of Sharia Law. And that's an LGBTQi community which the middle class white liberals usually tend to be sympathetic towards.

In my experience Muslims are generally quite cool about my reservations. Others I've mentioned super quick to trott out the 'Islamophobe' tag...
Click to expand...
If anything, I welcome your criticism and questions. Sharia law by definition says we follow the land of the country we in and do not seek to alter it.

Where I draw the line is when that discussion is met with ignoring fact or refusal to understand. If you want to have a genuine conversation, then by all means, but if you refuse to accept when wrong, then that's different
 
Monoethnic Social Club said:
Is Zionophobia greater than or equal to Islamophobia? You seem pretty quick to push others to "reflect" but you don't set the same path for yourself. Is your mirror somehow different?

Your "stolen lands" justification of killing innocent people (if thats what you mean) is disgusting... sorry but it really is.... How can indiscriminate killing of unarmed people be justifiable? -- And before you bother - OTHER crimes have been committed in the name of other other beliefs and they are also equally vile.... what makes Hamas and their cause above basic humanity? because they have suffered for 70 years? So what? Other, alot worthier, people have suffered for centuries.... If my neighbour builds a new fence and "steals" 10cms of my property, I fight him in court, Im not gonna rape his wife and drag his dead body through the mud.....
Click to expand...
Exactly. How can indiscriminate killing of unharmed people be acceptable. 70 plus years of it. Is it not a war? When you attack a people, will they not respond? 70 plus years of kling and attacks, and one response to it is where you draw the line. Not to.mention the immense disproportionate response to that one attack. Babies, children, women aid workers, doctors, journalists, all brutally murdered.

Call me a Zionophpbe. I'll wear it, because when your entire doctrine and ethos requires you to engage in apartheid and genocide, then I will be against you
 
zimbos05 said:
If anything, I welcome your criticism and questions. Sharia law by definition says we follow the land of the country we in and do not seek to alter it.

Where I draw the line is when that discussion is met with ignoring fact or refusal to understand. If you want to have a genuine conversation, then by all means, but if you refuse to accept when wrong, then that's different
Click to expand...
So why do some many examples of implemented or attempted implementation of sharia law in parallel societies in Europe go totally against the law of the land?

I get these are often through back room clerics who make little sense half the time. Do these examples count as bad examples of sharia?
 
zimbos05 said:
If anything, I welcome your criticism and questions.
Click to expand...
So if Hamas is given the opportunity to govern in a Palestinian State in a 'two state solution' in the territory of the former Mandatory Palestine what will happen to the LGBTQi communities in that state?

For instance.

Will two homosexuals or lesbians that are together as a couple in a relationship be allowed to have a same sex marriage?

Because at the moment same-sex sexual marriage is currently prohibited in Gaza as is same sex activity which carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment.
 
zimbos05 said:
Exactly. How can indiscriminate killing of unharmed people be acceptable. 70 plus years of it. Is it not a war? When you attack a people, will they not respond? 70 plus years of kling and attacks, and one response to it is where you draw the line. Not to.mention the immense disproportionate response to that one attack. Babies, children, women aid workers, doctors, journalists, all brutally murdered.

Call me a Zionophpbe. I'll wear it, because when your entire doctrine and ethos requires you to engage in apartheid and genocide, then I will be against you
Click to expand...
ITS NOT!!!!!!!!!!! Neither from one side OR the other thats what Ive been typing over and over and over about....

The IDF attacks Palestinians, kills women and children like the animals their masters tell them to be and Hamas' response is to what? .... Kill women and children on the other side? Is that going to bring their women and children back, terror in response to terror? eye for an eye?

Anyway, Im done I dont have a "side" in this war... I think they are both wrong and right at the same time... Both think they are on the side of the "righteous" walking with God but BOTH are slaughtering each other like animals..... the winner will be either Russia or US.... you guys can fight it out over scraps.... so very very sad.
 
Football us life said:
So if Hamas is given the opportunity to govern in a Palestinian State in a 'two state solution' in the territory of the former Mandatory Palestine what will happen to the LGBTQi communities in that state?

For instance.

Will two homosexuals or lesbians that are together as a couple in a relationship be allowed to have a same sex marriage?

Because at the moment same-sex sexual marriage and same sex activity is currently prohibited in Gaza and carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment.
Click to expand...
Thats pretty progressive to be fair... some parts of the world still call the dude with the axe to these trials....
 
Monoethnic Social Club said:
How so? How many Jewish teachers are at Islamic Colleges Australia wide?
Click to expand...
Curriculum is what you teach, discrimination is prejudice based on a person's race or religion. You can teach religious education as long as it aligns with curriculum. You shouldn't be making decisions based on a person's skin colour or religion

I know of 4 Jewish teachers at one Islamic college
 
Football us life said:
So if Hamas is given the opportunity to govern in a Palestinian State in a 'two state solution' in the territory of the former Mandatory Palestine what will happen to the LGBTQi communities in that state?

For instance.

Will two homosexuals or lesbians that are together as a couple in a relationship be allowed to have a same sex marriage?

Because at the moment same-sex sexual marriage is currently prohibited in Gaza as is same sex activity which carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment.
Click to expand...
Oh god, this again.

I don't know because I'm not Hamas. Same-sex marriage is prohibited in many non Muslim countries at the moment too, are you in uproar at that
 
Monoethnic Social Club said:
Thats pretty progressive to be fair... some parts of the world still call the dude with the axe to these trials....
Click to expand...
And that's kind of the crux of my entire argument. Israel has pretty liberal laws concerning homosexuality. Haifa has one of the highest per capita populations of homosexuals in the world. Now Haifa is a very young, progressive 'tech city', much like San Francisco in that sense but across the whole state of Israel the LGBTQi community is still quite large in comparison to most other countries.

It would be unfortunate if homosexuality was banned in area's that were returned to the Palestinians and put under the governance of a group like Hamas.

In the West Bank under the Palestinian Authority its far more liberal. But the Palestinian Authority don't have the numbers that Hamas would have in any democratic election.
 
zimbos05 said:
Oh god, this again.

I don't know because I'm not Hamas. Same-sex marriage is prohibited in many non Muslim countries at the moment too, are you in uproar at that
Click to expand...
Yes I am. It's abhorrent in 2025 ffs. Abhorrent. And stop demeaning the plight of these LGBTQi communities as oh god nor this again....it's disgraceful.

They have experienced horrendous bigotry and been more marginalised than perhaps any group of people across the entire planet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top