Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

Sign Up Now!

Which Book Are You Reading thread

Decentric

Fan Favourite
Joined
Oct 17, 2024
Replies
1,023
Good day all.

I know Mr Cleansheets is a published author.

Do we have any others who are avid readers, mainly fiction?

I've been on a Which Book Are You reading thread for years on another forum. All participants are highly literate, mainly female, and there has been no trolling, and virtually no animosity.

However:

1. Published authors can't promote their books, or disclose their identity to promote them. As a point of difference on G and G we could have an authors ' thread. Most of us love reading and are far too lazy to write books. We love authors who write!

2. The main tension has to be spoilers. That is disclosing how a book concludes to people who haven't read it. Recently a Mod deleted a lot of comments, where two posters, who most of us disagreed with, claimed by posting info about a late Ian Rankin book (publicly advertised in bookshops and online) , that it was a spoiler.

By discussing this in the thread, I was banned for a week! Not because of what I said, but because of where it was discussed in the thread - the norm in every other setting. We also wanted to appoint our own Mods - not someone uninvolved who had just made a poor decision adjudicating.

If we have a number here already interested, I don't need to recruit as many to make it viable.
 
Or we could just post what books we are reading/have read or will read. That simplifies things somewhat.

I'll start. A book about the origin of interest charged on money.

1738544766872.webp
 
  • Like
Reactions: tsf
Why is everything about trolling, animosity, anonymity, and mods for you?
It isn't.

It might surprise you, but in some settings, members of some forums are civil and respectful to each other - all the time. If a book reading thread is viable on this forum, I want to ascertain genuine interest from pre-existing G and G posters. Another member of G and G, off forum, thought it was an excellent idea.

Trying to start sub-sections of forums from scratch can be challenging. The book readers from the other forum aren't going to engage, or hang around, if posters interject with lots of facetious comments, or try to derail the thread/s.
 
It isn't.

It might surprise you, but in some settings, members of some forums are civil and respectful to each other - all the time. If a book reading thread is viable on this forum, I want to ascertain genuine interest from pre-existing G and G posters. Another member of G and G, off forum, thought it was an excellent idea.

Trying to start sub-sections of forums from scratch can be challenging. The book readers from the other forum aren't going to engage, or hang around, if posters interject with lots of facetious comments, or try to derail the thread/s.
If its anything like the cricket section of this forums then I have to say Im against the idea... This, primarily, SHOULD be a football forum with other topics as a secondary conversation... In my opinion anyway...

Absolutely NOTHING against people talking about their passions, cricket, Donald Trump, Transvestism, a specific rugby union club or whatever... but this IS Green and Gold FC and I would think that members would at least pretend to congrate to discuss football?
 
If its anything like the cricket section of this forums then I have to say Im against the idea... This, primarily, SHOULD be a football forum with other topics as a secondary conversation... In my opinion anyway...

Absolutely NOTHING against people talking about their passions, cricket, Donald Trump, Transvestism, a specific rugby union club or whatever... but this IS Green and Gold FC and I would think that members would at least pretend to congrate to discuss football?
Good to see a position advanced, Mono.

What about all the other sports covered in Other Sports section? Are you happy with people covering them?
 
Good to see a position advanced, Mono.

What about all the other sports covered in Other Sports section? Are you happy with people covering them?
Please dont misunderstand, I am MORE than happy for all sports and ALL topics to be discussed (thats what I see Off topic space being for) I would just hate for this place to become an Inside Sport/Roar type clone... FOOTBALL IS LIFE ... everything else is a distraction :)
 
Please dont misunderstand, I am MORE than happy for all sports and ALL topics to be discussed (thats what I see Off topic space being for) I would just hate for this place to become an Inside Sport/Roar type clone... FOOTBALL IS LIFE ... everything else is a distraction :)
I'm thrilled you have accepted the AL is life, Mono! You've come a long way!

By recruiting more members, some might stay and follow the football threads? It might not happen too.
 
Im reading Anna Karenina currently BTW ... Don't ask, I went down a Tolstoy rabbit hole just before Christmas.... was debating Ukraine with my brother .... loooong story. :)
 
Im reading Anna Karenina currently BTW ... Don't ask, I went down a Tolstoy rabbit hole just before Christmas.... was debating Ukraine with my brother .... loooong story. :)
If you are that interested - good.

A couple more and I'll start recruiting - after I talk to Pasquali - as it is his forum.

I've got three author mates too. They'd love to do Q and As.

Without any spoilers - why did you pursue an older historical works?

Any interesting observations about the plot? Characters?
 
Good day all.

I know Mr Cleansheets is a published author.

Do we have any others who are avid readers, mainly fiction?

I've been on a Which Book Are You reading thread for years on another forum. All participants are highly literate, mainly female, and there has been no trolling, and virtually no animosity.

However:

1. Published authors can't promote their books, or disclose their identity to promote them. As a point of difference on G and G we could have an authors ' thread. Most of us love reading and are far too lazy to write books. We love authors who write!

2. The main tension has to be spoilers. That is disclosing how a book concludes to people who haven't read it. Recently a Mod deleted a lot of comments, where two posters, who most of us disagreed with, claimed by posting info about a late Ian Rankin book (publicly advertised in bookshops and online) , that it was a spoiler.

By discussing this in the thread, I was banned for a week! Not because of what I said, but because of where it was discussed in the thread - the norm in every other setting. We also wanted to appoint our own Mods - not someone uninvolved who had just made a poor decision adjudicating.

If we have a number here already interested, I don't need to recruit as many to make it viable.

Instead of starting a thread about the possibility of starting a thread, why didn't you just call this thread "Which book are you reading?", post the book(s) you're currently reading and see how the thread goes?
That seems like a much simpler option.

For the record;
My favourite authors are Stephen King (I'm more a fan of his storytelling abilities in general - not specifically his horror stories) and Harry Turtledove (his World War/Civilisation series is my all-time favourite book series and gets a re-read from me about every 5 years).

Currently reading: "The woman who went to bed for a year" by Sue Townsend. Found it at a 2nd hand store, title was intriguing. It's amusing enough, although I dare say it's target audience would be middle aged women.
 
If you are that interested - good.

A couple more and I'll start recruiting - after I talk to Pasquali - as it is his forum.

I've got three author mates too. They'd love to do Q and As.

Without any spoilers - why did you pursue an older historical works?

Any interesting observations about the plot? Characters?
Dinner table conversation revolved around historical conflicts... you know the same old "nobody can invade Russia, the winters are too harsh" thing, then
"what that does to the "psyche" of the Russian people"?.
How does it come across in art, architecture and literature ?.... "
Oh I should ready War and Peace again ...
lets start of with something more "fun" the story of a fallen women :)

Told you "don't ask" hahahahahaahah
 
Dinner table conversation revolved around historical conflicts... you know the same old "nobody can invade Russia, the winters are too harsh" thing, then
"what that does to the "psyche" of the Russian people"?.
How does it come across in art, architecture and literature ?.... "
Oh I should ready War and Peace again ...
lets start of with something more "fun" the story of a fallen women :)

Told you "don't ask" hahahahahaahah
Bit of trivia...

Only one army has successfully invaded Moscow during winter.
1738562311330.png
 
Instead of starting a thread about the possibility of starting a thread, why didn't you just call this thread "Which book are you reading?", post the book(s) you're currently reading and see how the thread goes?
That seems like a much simpler option.

For the record;
My favourite authors are Stephen King (I'm more a fan of his storytelling abilities in general - not specifically his horror stories) and Harry Turtledove (his World War/Civilisation series is my all-time favourite book series and gets a re-read from me about every 5 years).

Currently reading: "The woman who went to bed for a year" by Sue Townsend. Found it at a 2nd hand store, title was intriguing. It's amusing enough, although I dare say it's target audience would be middle aged women.
Also a big fan of Mr King .... Havent read Turtledove but you have piqued my interest...

A
 
Also a big fan of Mr King .... Havent read Turtledove but you have piqued my interest...

A
His area of speciality is alternate history.

So... if you're interested in a story where Aliens with '90s level tech arrive in the middle of WW2 expecting an easy win, or the Japanese capture Hawaii after Pearl Harbour, or WW2 "officially" kicks off when Germany invades Czechoslovakia instead of Poland, or the Korean War goes Nuclear, etc, you'll enjoy his stuff.

 
His area of speciality is alternate history.

So... if you're interested in a story where Aliens with '90s level tech arrive in the middle of WW2 expecting an easy win, or the Japanese capture Hawaii after Pearl Harbour, or WW2 "officially" kicks off when Germany invades Czechoslovakia instead of Poland, or the Korean War goes Nuclear, etc, you'll enjoy his stuff.

YES PLEASE .... I read the Axis of Time trilogy by John Birmingham and really liked it.... Similar sort of premise minus the aliens ... think relatively believable future tech plopped in the middle of the battle of Midway .. Hitler with an ipad reading about the bunker sort of thing .... pretty cool.

 
Back
Top