Muz
Fan Favourite
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2024
- Replies
- 1,178
- Thread Author
- #2,161
And got this.
--------------------------------------------------------8<-----------------------------------------------------------
Here's a comparative breakdown, adding a third column to examine parallels between Hitler’s rise and Trump’s rhetoric or actions during his second election campaign. While there are similarities in themes, the historical contexts are different.
--------------------------------------------------------8<-----------------------------------------------------------
Here's a comparative breakdown, adding a third column to examine parallels between Hitler’s rise and Trump’s rhetoric or actions during his second election campaign. While there are similarities in themes, the historical contexts are different.
| Original Paragraph | Verdict & Reasoning | Trump Comparison |
|---|---|---|
| In 1923 Adolf Hitler incited an insurrection against the German government. He was tried, given a slap on the wrist, and became a convicted felon. Despite being treated charitably by the judge, Hitler claimed the trial was political persecution and successfully portrayed himself as a victim of the “corrupt" Social Democrats. | Partially True – Hitler led the Beer Hall Putsch in 1923, was convicted of treason, and served a short sentence. He framed himself as a political martyr. | Trump’s role in the January 6th Capitol riot led to his second impeachment, though he was acquitted. He has since portrayed legal cases against him as a "witch hunt" and "political persecution" by corrupt Democrats. |
| Hitler cleverly positioned himself as the voice of the "common man," railing against the "elites," cultural "degeneracy," and the establishment, who he all labeled as "Marxists." He claimed the education system was indoctrinating children to hate Germany and promised to return Germany to greatness. | Mostly True – Hitler framed himself as fighting for ordinary Germans against "Marxists" and cultural decay. | Trump presents himself as the champion of the "forgotten" working-class American. He attacks "elites," opposes progressive education (claiming schools indoctrinate children), and promotes "Make America Great Again." |
| To solidify his base, Hitler masterfully scapegoated minorities for the nation's problems, exploiting societal divisions with an "us vs. them" narrative. Many Germans took the bait. Hitler's Nazi Party continued to gain traction until he became Chancellor in 1933. | True – Hitler blamed Jews, communists, and other minorities for Germany’s problems. | Trump has frequently blamed immigrants, particularly from Latin America, for crime and economic issues. He has used racial and cultural divisions to energize his base. |
| Hitler appointed German oligarchs as his economic advisors. He proceeded to privatize government-run utilities, solidifying support of the economic elite. | Partially True – Hitler collaborated with industrialists and privatized some industries but also expanded state control. | Trump appointed billionaires and corporate leaders to his cabinet, cut taxes for the wealthy, and deregulated industries, benefiting corporate elites. |
| With the working class divided along cultural and ethnic lines, the Nazis shut down workers' unions and abolished strikes. | True – The Nazis banned independent unions and strikes. | Trump has weakened labor protections, opposed union efforts, and appointed pro-business officials to labor boards. |
| Progressives and trade unionists were imprisoned and sent to concentration camps. Corporate profits skyrocketed while working-class Germans lived paycheck to paycheck. | Partially True – The Nazis persecuted leftists, while corporations profited. Some working-class Germans did benefit from state programs. | Trump hasn’t imprisoned political opponents but has vilified progressives and the left as "communists" and "Marxists." His policies favored corporations, and economic inequality widened under his administration. |
| Hitler, who became a billionaire while in office, knew he and his clan of oligarchs could get away with the scam if they constantly had an "enemy within" to blame while the corporatocracy robbed the country blind. | Partially True – Hitler accumulated immense wealth through tax avoidance and state perks. | Trump leveraged the presidency for personal business gains, funneled government funds to his properties, and frequently blamed minorities, Democrats, and the media for national problems. |
| An easy target was one of the smallest minorities. Hitler removed birthright citizenship rights of Jews and started rounding them up for mass deportations for being "illegally" in the country. | Mostly True – Jews were stripped of citizenship under the Nuremberg Laws. | Trump attempted to end birthright citizenship, enforced strict immigration policies, and separated families at the border, leading to mass deportations. |
| The German press under Nazi rule highlighted instances of violence by Jews to convince the public that Jewish immigrants were a danger to the "real Germans." | Partially True – Nazi propaganda portrayed Jews as criminals and subversives. | Trump has frequently amplified stories of crimes committed by immigrants, particularly from Mexico and the Middle East, to justify harsher immigration policies. |
| Hitler wasted no time dismantling democratic institutions. Loyalty wasn't just encouraged; it was demanded. Opponents were silenced. Media that dared to question him were vilified as "the enemy" and "Marxists." | True – Hitler consolidated power quickly, eliminated opposition, and controlled the press. | Trump repeatedly called the media "the enemy of the people," dismissed government oversight, and sought to overturn election results he lost. |
| Hitler's Propaganda Minister, Joseph Goebbels, bragged about how the Nazis were able to intimidate the media into giving them favorable coverage, and didn't need to give direct orders. | Partially True – Goebbels controlled the media through coercion and direct influence. | Trump regularly attacked the press, favored right-wing media like Fox News, and pressured media outlets to align with his narratives. |
| The Nazi regime and its followers collected all books they saw as promoting "degeneracy" or what would be considered "woke" today, and burned them in large bonfires. They also burned books that promoted class consciousness. | Mostly True – Nazis burned books on socialism, LGBTQ issues, and liberal thought. | Trump and his supporters have opposed "woke" culture, sought to ban books about race and LGBTQ issues in schools, and pushed for curriculum restrictions. |
| Berlin had a thriving LGBTQ community in the 1920s, and even had the first transgender clinic. The Nazis burned it to the ground. LGBTQ people were sent to concentration camps and forced to wear triangle badges. Many were killed in the Holocaust. | True – The Nazis persecuted LGBTQ people severely. | Trump rolled back LGBTQ protections, banned transgender individuals from military service, and emboldened anti-LGBTQ rhetoric among his supporters. |
| The Nazis also saw manhood as under threat by independent women who didn't rely on men. In 1934, Hitler proclaimed, “A woman's world is her husband, her family, her children, her house." Laws that had protected women's rights were repealed and new laws were introduced to restrict women to the home and in their roles as wives and mothers. | True – The Nazis promoted traditional gender roles. | Trump has made statements reinforcing traditional gender roles, opposed feminist movements, and rolled back reproductive rights. |
| Reproductive rights were severely rolled back, and doctors who performed abortions could face the death penalty. | Mostly True – Abortion was criminalized under the Nazis. | Trump appointed Supreme Court justices who overturned Roe v. Wade, leading to severe abortion restrictions in many states. |
| Despite all of this, the German people didn't have a similar historical parallel to look upon as a warning. | True – There was no precedent for Nazi Germany at the time. | The U.S. does have historical parallels, including authoritarian tendencies, racial persecution, and McCarthyism, yet many ignore these warnings. |
| Most Germans never acted like the sky was falling. Most just went along with their lives as usual, until many of their lives were snuffed out. | Partially True – Many Germans complied or ignored warning signs. | Many Americans dismiss concerns about authoritarianism, believing democracy will self-correct. |
| By the time Hitler's reign was forced to an end by the Allied Powers, 11 million people were murdered in the Holocaust, and 70-85 million were killed in WW2. | True – The Holocaust and WWII had catastrophic casualties. | While no direct parallel exists, Trump's rhetoric and policies have contributed to rising political violence and social division. |
